Opinion & Analysis
Buyer beware: The issues with golf coaching programs
Picture yourself at a crossroads, contemplating whether to enroll your child in a golf coaching program promising to unlock their potential and pave the path to collegiate golf success.
As you peruse the online mission statement, it becomes evident:
“Our coaching philosophy is dedicated to nurturing young talents for triumph in college golf. We employ cutting-edge scientific methods, including personality testing, to customize coaching for each individual. Emphasizing the importance of time management and a strong work ethic on the golf course and in the classroom, we recognize these principles as crucial not only in sports but in life. Golf serves as a platform for honing essential life skills such as discipline, perseverance, and fostering a growth mindset among our athletes. We appreciate the unique qualities of each golfer and strive to unleash their full potential through personalized coaching, viewing it as a partnership extending beyond technical skills. Our commitment is to holistic growth and well-being. If you aspire to elevate your child’s golf game, consider us as mentors.”
This mission statement brims with enticing buzzwords like deliberate practice, grit, science-backed methods, and a strong emphasis on academics. However, you may be pondering whether these buzzwords genuinely hold the key to success. Let’s explore what science and influential thinkers have to say on the topics of mentorship, the fixation on grades, the importance of practice and the objective of college golf.
Allow me to introduce you to the Somerville Youth Study, a research endeavor spanning decades since its inception in 1936. It aimed to answer a straightforward question: Does mentorship truly benefit children? The study divided children into two groups – one navigating life’s challenges independently and the other receiving academic guidance, medical support, and camaraderie from groups like the Boy Scouts. Surprisingly, those who ventured alone often thrived, challenging the prevailing belief in the transformative power of mentorship.
In “Barking up the Wrong Tree,” author Barker dismantles the notion that valedictorians are destined for unparalleled success. His analysis, rooted in research by Karen Arnold at Boston College, debunks this notion. While high school success correlates with college achievements, valedictorians rarely emerge as standout success stories in life. Instead, a survey of 700 millionaires reveals their average GPA was 2.9! Why? Because success transcends mere grades. Successful individuals possess the mental acumen to excel, but they are too engrossed in exploring, experimenting, and seizing various opportunities to be ensnared by the mundane details that often consume valedictorians.
Though we’ve been trained to believe that 10,000 hours of practice are critical for development, I must caution against this notion. Many coaches become entangled in the intricacies of technical aspects, perpetuating the illusion that mastering a solitary element can revolutionize a player’s game. The reality is that elite golfers possess a well-defined set of skills, and a coach’s role is to ensure junior players understand these skills and the fundamentals of executing shots – nothing more, nothing less.
The fact is college golf is not and should not be a destination. In fact, the evidence suggests that playing in college actually ruins most people’s relationship with golf making it a job, controlled by results rather than a genuine interest in developing skills, being with people, or just the pure joy of a nice walk in beautiful weather.
I hope that I have demonstrated that much of what we think our kids need from youth sports is not actually necessary. In fact, it is downright narcissistic. So what’s a parent to do? Encourage our kids to chase happiness. To explore golf on their own terms and learn when they need help and when they need time and space to just figure it out on their own.
- LIKE60
- LEGIT12
- WOW3
- LOL4
- IDHT0
- FLOP2
- OB0
- SHANK11
19th Hole
The biggest golf resort you never knew (but should)
As a Korean-Canadian and an avid golfer for over 35 years, I am fortunate to have played on many beautiful golf courses in the West and the Far East. I still have a boatload of courses like Pebble Beach and St. Andrews on my bucket list, but I came to learn that Asia had plenty of such places to visit as well.
I have recently had the good fortune of playing the iconic Blackstone Golf Club at Mission Hills Resort in China, which is consistently ranked as one of the best courses in Asia. Blackstone is particularly famous for hosting the Tiger Woods vs. Rory McIlroy exhibition ‘The Match at Mission Hills’ in 2013. The event brought international attention to the sprawling luxury resort and boosted the level of interest in the game in the region.
Before delving into my amazing experience at Blackstone Golf Club, here is a little bit of information about the best golf resort you may never heard of.
The Best Golf Resort in The World?
Mission Hills Golf and Resort is located in the southern part of China on Hainan Island, which is about the size of Maine. Often referred to as the Hawaii of China, its tropical location gives the island year-round sunshine with temperatures between 75~90°F in the winter and 60~75°F in the summer. Along with dozens of other notable golf resorts and courses on the Island, the resort is a popular destination for golfers from Asia, Europe, and as far away as Australia and New Zealand.
Mission Hills first opened its doors in early 2010 with the aim of becoming the best resort in the world. I’m not sure if they achieved their goal, but before you smirk at their ambitiousness, Mission Hills is currently listed in the Guinness Book of Records as the World’s largest golf resort with a total of 10 world-class golf courses. That is an astounding 180 championship-class golf holes in one resort! The courses are designed by the talented Schmidt-Curley Design team who are behind some of the best courses in Asia and around the world.
The Blackstone Golf Club is considered the “crown jewel” course at Mission Hills Resort and gets its name from the plethora of black lava rock that is found all over the course as part of its beautiful charm. But don’t be fooled by its rugged beauty, as the monster-long Blackstone has hosted several World Cup of Golf championships (guess who teamed up for the US to win in 2011?) and the annual World Ladies Championships. It also hosts the annual World Celebrity Pro-Am attended by an amazing A-list of screen stars, pro golfers, and elite athletes from around the world.
So yeah, the course is quite good.
On top of that, the resort holds another world’s best distinction, with a total of 168 different hot springs and pools within the resort. Unfortunately, I was too immersed in playing golf to take advantage of a good hot soak, but it will be on the top of my list to do with my whole family next time.
Now, let’s take a close look at what the Blackstone course was all about, and keep in mind that the course descriptions and opinions are all my own from experience and perspective.
Greens
The green condition was quite superb, albeit a bit slow from Western standards. According to the caddie, the green speed was measured at about 2.9 meters, which translates to about 9.5 on the stimp meter. A speed of 7 is considered to be slow, and the average PGA Tour event is said to be about 12, so for us average folk the greens were rolling well.
The green size is quite large with nearly 5700 square feet average in size with less-than-subtle undulations and big rolling plateaus. The pins were placed slightly towards the front left of the green this day, and the approach shots were challenging for us amateurs to stuff close. The ball rolled straight and true to where it was aimed, and I only had myself to blame for missed short putts.
Fairways
Unlike many of the Korean courses I’m used to, the fairways are lush and readily yielded nice dollar-sized divots from well-struck iron shots into the greens. The course itself is huge and it was reflected in the long wide fairways stretching from tee to green.
Most of the fairways seemed to be free of readily noticeable trouble areas, meaning that what you see was what you got. However, upon close inspection, there were many subtle undulations which caused the stance to be slightly uneven at address. It wasn’t like St. Andrews level of fairway undulations, but it was there.
Also, the big prominent fairways bunkers often came into play and caused me to consciously aim away from them, which left longer approach shots into the green. We were somehow feeling confident this day and were playing from the blue tees. And for a guy who averages 240-yard drives on my best days, those small detours inevitably added 1-2 clubs more to the next shot.
Rough
Truth to tell, the rough wasn’t all that intimidating, as it was only modestly long, and the wide fairways pushed the rough back considerably. As it wasn’t tournament season and the course was set up to mostly cater to vacationers, it made sense not to make the rough too punishing.
Beyond the rough was mostly deep jungle-like vegetation, which made it next to impossible to hit the ball out of, let alone find it in the first place. Thanks to our amateur ball-striking abilities, however, we easily overpowered the hapless wide fairways to appease the jungle gods with our many golf balls.
Bunkers
Blackstone had no shortage of fairway and greenside bunkers to daunt the average golfer. The many fairway bunkers were often quite large, and despite the mostly wide fairways, some were placed just at the right (?) places to catch drives that strayed left or right off the tee. Standing on the tees, the presence of so many bunkers was aesthetically pleasing yet intimidating at the same time.
The bunkers were meticulously raked and pristine, with the sand looking visually heavy but being very soft. Maintaining the bunkers to this level of readiness cannot be easy, as there are 10 courses at this resort! Even if there were just two bunkers per hole, that’s still 360 sand traps to rake and prep each day! Add to this the fairways and greens, not to mention the decorative foliage, the level of course maintenance at this level is quite mind-boggling.
I also don’t recall seeing any flat bunkers, as most seemed to have a healthy amount of incline at the front to make it harder to move the ball forward a long way. The greenside bunkers were also deeper and usually presented an upslope lie, and the shots had to have some climb to escape from them. If you have trouble hitting the ball straight, be sure to sharpen your bunker play when you visit Blackstone.
Tee To Green
Blackstone’s monstrous 7808 yards should satisfy most golfers’ urge to go all out on their shots. From the blues, it was still a challenging 6722 yards, and I don’t mind saying it felt longer than that all day.
Most of the pins can be seen from the tee box, and despite some slightly rolling fairways, Blackstone is a mostly-level parkland course without any significant drop or rise in elevation. Sprawling over a huge area of land, the holes do not double back in parallel but stretch forward through dense foliage, making for a scenic ride in the golf cart. One thing I also appreciated was the leisurely pace of play. The group ahead and behind were not visible for nearly the entire round, despite our less-than-quick pace of play.
From tee to green in its entirety, the course was in amazing shape and condition. The unexpected tropical golf experience was nothing short of amazing, and if I had to make a comparison to some of the other memorable tracks I’ve visited, the Hoakalei Country Club and Turtle Bay Resort (Palmer design) in Hawaii come to mind, along with Korea’s own Haesley Nine Bridge Club, which consistently ranks as one of the best courses in Asia.
The pictures below don’t do justice to the course, but I’m sure you’ll get the idea.
Caddies & Carts
Unlike most courses in the West, golf clubs in Asia require each golfer to play with a mandatory caddie and golf cart. Also, if you each decide to have an additional caddie to help hold the umbrella, it can make for a sizeable group of 12 (greens keepers would be tossing in their beds in the west)! So how do the caddies move if you’re driving a power cart, you ask? They simply hop onboard the back of the buggy.
On this day, we ‘only’ had four caddies to attend our play, and they were fantastic. Despite my initial concerns, the language barrier was not an issue as they were conversant in all the needed terminology in English and Korean. This was a pleasant surprise, as I was able to ask more about the course to help my play, and there was always Google Translate.
The caddie fee was 500 yuan each, which is about $70 US. They were highly professional and quick on their feet, and I could tell that the resort had gone to good lengths in training the caddies (said to be 2000 in number!) to make the golfing experience enjoyable for their international guests.
Resort & Facilities
Mission Hills Haikou has a 500-room hotel with several fine-dining restaurants and high-end boutiques within the main wing and the adjoining annex. They also have a shopping mall within the hotel featuring global brands like Taylormade, Adidas, and Skechers, along with a slew of high-end golf brands to luxury watches and whiskies.
The view from my room on the 9th floor was something to write home about, along with the impeccable services. Truth to tell, I had previously heard several horror stories of less-than-friendly services which led me to refrain from visiting China prior. That must’ve been a different country, as Mission Hills pulled out all the stops to impress and awe its visitors, and it certainly worked on me. We were treated like kings on and off the course, and the hotel personnel was on hand to assist us everywhere we went.
The entire resort complex was like a huge labyrinth of spas, pools, shops, and golf courses. They nearly had everything, including an incredible hotel buffet and several ethnic cuisines, a nightclub and karaoke, and an entire museum-like wing dedicated to the many celebrities and pro golfers that have played here. I could have stayed for hours simply looking at their vast collection of golf memorabilia. My golf buddy called it a golf heaven on earth, and I couldn’t agree more.
Again, the pics won’t be able to fully capture the experience, but they’ll give you an idea of the enormous size and quality of the place.
Hotel Shops & Amenities
Then there were dozens more shops in a whole other building next to the hotel, lined with the palm prints of celebrities and stars. The sheer size and scale of Mission Hills was outrageous.
Trip Overview
- LIKE27
- LEGIT4
- WOW4
- LOL0
- IDHT0
- FLOP0
- OB1
- SHANK6
19th Hole
Vincenzi: 2024 WM Phoenix Open First Round Leader picks
The Waste Management Phoenix Open begins on Thursday in what is sure to be one of the most exciting events of the year. The PGA Tour is back to playing one course per event, which I find to be much more conducive to first round leader betting.
In the past five editions of the tournament, there have been nine first-round leaders or co-leaders. Of the nine, five have come from the morning wave, and four have come from the afternoon wave. It appears there is no real advantage to either starting time historically but that can always be influenced by weather.
As of Tuesday, the wind looks as if it may be a factor during round one. The early starters should see winds 8 MPH with gusts up to 18 MPH. The afternoon starters will have the slightly more difficult draw. Winds will be around 16 MPH with gusts up to 22 MPH. For this reason, I’d slightly favor AM starters but wouldn’t rule out the PM wave completely.
Waste Management Phoenix Open First-Round-Leader Selections
Keith Mitchell +9000 (Bet365)
First-Round Tee Time: 12:22 p.m. Local Time
TPC Scottsdale is the type of course where Keith Mitchell’s skill set could propel him up the leaderboard. He will be able to let it fly off the tee and is always capable of getting a hot putter. Mitchell has had some success in the event, finishing 10th in 2022 while shooting four rounds in the 60’s. He also finished 16th in 2020.
K.H. Lee +10000 (FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM)
First-Round Tee Time: 12:55 p.m. Local Time
K.H. Lee famously has played great golf at TPC courses, and TPC Scottsdale is no different. The South Korean came agonizingly close to victory at the event back in 2021, finishing one shot behind Brooks Koepka.
Lee missed the cut at The Farmers but had back-to-back top-30 finishes in his previous two starts at some easier courses in Waialae CC and PGA West. K.H. shot three rounds of 66 at the course when he contended so he’s no stranger to a low round at TPC Scottsdale.
Sam Ryder +12500 (Bet365)
First-Round Tee Time: 12:00 p.m. Local Time
Sam Ryder has been a boom-or-bust player, which is exactly what we’re looking for in a first-round leader bet. The 34-year-old recently had a hot stretch with the irons and is always a go-low candidate on easier courses.
Last year, Ryder finished 20th at the event, and he finished 23rd in 2022, but had a 2nd round 64, which would likely be good enough for FRL if he were able to repeat.
Victor Perez +15000 (BetMGM)
First-Round Tee Time: 9:10 a.m. Local Time
Victor Perez hasn’t played much in 2024, so this is more of a gut play than anything else. He missed the cut in his only start at the Farmers Insurance Open but was able to still gain strokes with his irons despite the disappointing finish.
Perez was playing great in the fall and finished 8th at the DPWT Championship. A week on the PGA Tour at Torrey Pines should have been enough to get his feet wet and feel comfortable this week in Phoenix on a course where his strong iron play could help him shoot a low round.
Adrien Dumont De Chessart+20000 (Bet365)
First-Round Tee Time: 1:50 p.m. Local Time
This is yet another gut play with Dumont De Chessart. The 23-year-old from Belgium has enormous upside and one of the more talented young players in the world but has struggled to start his PGA Tour career.
De Chessart opened his Farmers Insurance Open with a first-round 68, which was a solid score on a tough track. The laid-back atmosphere of TPC Scottsdale and the scoreable layout could be enough for the rookie to find the form that made him a threat to win multiple Korn Ferry Tour events at the end of last season.
- LIKE6
- LEGIT1
- WOW1
- LOL0
- IDHT1
- FLOP2
- OB0
- SHANK0
19th Hole
Vincenzi’s 2024 WM Phoenix Open betting preview: Star names to shine in the desert
After a windy week at Pebble Beach, golf fans will be treated to an outstanding field at one of the best tournaments for viewing of the season. The raucous crowd at the famous 16th hole followed by a memorable finishing stretch of holes has turned into a Super Bowl Sunday staple leading up to the big game.
The Waste Management Phoenix Open is no longer a “signature event”, as it was last year, but it has still attracted a very solid group of players. The field will feature plenty of stars including Matt Fitzpatrick, Rickie Fowler, Viktor Hovland, Sungjae Im, Jordan Spieth, Cameron Young, Xander Schauffele, Scottie Scheffler, Justin Thomas, Sahith Theegala and Adam Scott.
TPC Scottsdale is a par-71 that measures 7,261 yards and features Bermudagrass greens (although they are much more of a blend rather than pure Bermudagrass).
Past Winners at the Waste Management Phoenix Open
- 2023: Scottie Scheffler (-19)
- 2022: Scottie Scheffler (-22)
- 2021: Brooks Koepka (-19)
- 2020: Webb Simpson (-17)
- 2019: Rickie Fowler (-17)
- 2018: Gary Woodland (-18)
- 2017: Hideki Matsuyama (-17)
- 2016: Hideki Matsuyama (-14)
- 2015: Brooks Koepka (-15)
Let’s take a look at several metrics for TPC Scottsdale to determine which golfers boast top marks in each category over their last 24 rounds:
Going forward, I’ll be using the brand-new Bet The Number data engine to develop my custom model. All statistics listed come directly from the PGA Tour. If you want to build your own model or check out all of the detailed stats, you can sign up using promo code: MATT for $5 off the Monthly and $50 off the Annual Subscription.
Strokes Gained: Approach
Approach will once again be very important this week.
Last year, Scottie Scheffler gained 9.1 strokes on approach on his way to victory. In 2021, Brooks Koepka was second in the field in Strokes Gained: Approach, trailing only Jordan Spieth, who finished fourth. In 2020, Webb Simpson ranked first in the field in the category en route to a playoff victory over Tony Finau.
The greens are relatively flat, and pins should be accessible.
Total Strokes Gained: Approach in Past 24 Rounds (per round):
- Xander Schauffele (+1.1)
- Mark Hubbard (+.91)
- Taylor Montgomery (+.90)
- Scottie Scheffler (+.89)
- Beau Hossler (+.86)
SG: Off the Tee
TPC Scottsdale is not an overly long golf course. Distance off the tee is not absolutely essential, but it is a definite asset. A good combination of distance and accuracy should be the recipe this week, with distance still being a bit more important.
SG: OTT in Past 24 Rounds (per round):
- Kevin Yu (+1.0)
- Scottie Scheffler (+.95)
- Keith Mitchell (+.91)
- Byeong Hun An (+.86)
- Jhonnatan Vegas (+.81)
Strokes Gained: Putting
Greens tend to get really firm and fast in the Arizona desert. Statistically, players will have to putt well to contend.
Strokes Gained: Putting in last 24 rounds:
- Min Woo Lee (+1.3)
- Sam Ryder (+1.3)
- Chad Ramey (+1.2)
- Taylor Montgomery (+1.1)
- Matt Kuchar (+1.0)
Greens in Regulation Percentage
Statistics from previous years at TPC Scottsdale say Greens in Regulation: Gained at the course is much more indicative of the winner at this tournament than TOUR average.
With many bunkers and firm dry areas around the greens, missing the putting surface can be consequential.
Total Greens in Regulation Gained: Gained in Past 24 Rounds
- Scottie Scheffler (+82.8%)
- Andrew Putnam (+82.6%)
- Corey Conners (+80.7%)
- Lucas Glover (+80.3%)
- Erik Van Rooyen (+80.2%)
Bogey Avoidance
With the winner in the high teens under par on average, making a lot of bogeys will make it incredibly difficult to contend.
Bogey Avoidance: Past 24 Rounds
- Ryan Moore (+7.1)
- Andrew Putnam (+7.9)
- Scottie Scheffler (+8.3)
- Alex Noren (+8.3)
- Viktor Hovland (+8.4)
Statistical Model
Below, I’ve reported overall model rankings using a combination of the five key statistical categories previously discussed.
These rankings are comprised of SG: App (28%), SG: OTT (25%), SG: Putting (17%), GIR %(18%) and Bogey Avoidance (12%).
- Scottie Scheffler (+550)
- Xander Schauffele (+1100)
- Corey Conners (+7000)
- Sam Ryder (+18000)
- Adam Svensson (+13000)
- Erik Van Rooyen (+11000)
- Viktor Hovland (+1100)
- Chesson Hadley (+10000)
- Taylor Montgomery (+8000)
- Max Homa (+1600)
2024 Waste Management Phoenix Open Picks
Justin Thomas +1400 (DraftKings)
Justin Thomas has been on fire to kick off his 2024 season. He finished 3rd at the American Express and put another great week together at Pebble Beach, finishing in a tie for 6th. Now he will be heading to a course that he absolutely loves in search of his first victory since the 2022 PGA Championship.
Thomas has played some great golf at TPC Scottsdale. He finished 4th at the course last year and 8th in 2022, gaining 7.1 strokes on approach, which was second in the field behind only Bubba Watson. Additionally, Thomas has third place finishes in both 2019 and 2020 as well as a 13th place finish in 2021.
The Waste Management Phoenix Open is an event I’ve always thought Justin Thomas was destined to win. As we’ve seen at both the Ryder Cup and the President’s Cup, “JT” is a player who thrives off of energy from the crowd, and he’ll certainly get his fair share of that this week in Scottsdale.
Jordan Spieth +2200 (DraftKings)
Spieth hit the ball pretty well at Pebble Beach but just couldn’t get many putts to fall. The former Masters champion has played well at TPC Scottsdale throughout his career, and this should be another event where he has a chance to contend, especially with the field a bit weaker this week.
Last year at the Waste Management Phoenix Open, Spieth finished in 6th place and gained 11.5 strokes from tee to green including an incredible 8.4 of those strokes on approach, which was second only to the winner Scottie Scheffler. He also has past finishes of 4th in 2021 and 9th in 2017.
Spieth has had a strong start to his season, finishing 3rd at The Sentry prior to a mediocre week at Pebble Beach. Spieth in contention would be a great scene on Super Bowl Sunday.
- LIKE20
- LEGIT6
- WOW3
- LOL2
- IDHT2
- FLOP3
- OB1
- SHANK3
-
19th Hole2 days ago
Brandel Chamblee outlines what his tough road back to PGA Tour would look like for LIV pros
-
19th Hole6 days ago
Bryson DeChambeau using irons from unique brand that offers clubs that nobody else does
-
19th Hole3 weeks ago
A huge hint over who will provide Tiger Woods’ new clothing line just dropped
-
19th Hole6 days ago
2-time major champ signs multi-year deal with Callaway Golf
-
19th Hole2 weeks ago
Ashley Perez aims multiple digs at Pat Perez after filing for divorce from LIV pro
-
19th Hole1 week ago
‘I wasn’t aware that rule was changed’ – Rory McIlroy suffers 2-stroke penalty at AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am
-
19th Hole6 days ago
Sergio Garcia uses putter that even most equipment junkies won’t have heard of before
-
19th Hole6 days ago
Wyndham Clark hails one big equipment alteration after Pebble Beach win